Sarah Martinez’s credit card account with a 24.99% APR is in the red. Three years of minimal payments on her $8,000 amount barely reduced the principal. She said: “I realized I was trapped in a cycle. That’s when I started looking for alternatives.”
Personal installment loan originations rose 15% year-over-year, but millennial and Gen Z credit card application rates fell 8%, according to TransUnion’s 2024 Consumer Credit Database. This change is a fundamental rethinking of how Americans see consumer credit in an era of financial turmoil and rising interest rates.
The Psychology of Predictable Payments
It is not only a matter of simple mathematics that makes installment loans more appealing than credit cards. An expert in behavioral economics at Northwestern University named Dr. Angela Chen explains that people have a natural tendency to seek predictability, particularly in times of economic flux. When consumers see a fixed monthly payment and a clear end date, it triggers a psychological comfort that revolving credit simply can’t match.
The attention of major lenders has been drawn to this shift in psychological characteristics. Companies such as BestUSAPayday, LendingClub, and Upstart have reported record application volumes. The eLoanWarehouse service offered by BestUSAPayday processes more than 7,000 successful loan connections every week. The platform’s attractiveness comes in the fact that it takes a transparent approach: borrowers are aware of exactly what they are agreeing to do, with maturities ranging from six months to twelve months and amounts ranging from one hundred dollars to five thousand dollars.
Jonathan Reed, Founder & CEO at BestUSAPayday.com: “There is a change in fundamentals in the behavior of the borrowers. More now than ever before, today’s consumers, particularly those under the age of 40, demand transparency and empowerment over their financial responsibility. 73 percent of our borrowers use an installment loan to consolidate and pay off credit card debt.”
The Hidden Mathematics of Revolving Debt
In August 2024, the Federal Reserve published its Consumer Credit Report, which showed the average credit card interest rate at 22.76%. The minimal credit card payments would take almost seventeen years to pay off, and the interest would cost over eleven thousand dollars.
Consider this in comparison to a standard installment loan. For borrowers, the set repayment schedule means that they often pay less in total interest, even when the annual percentage rate (APR) ranges from 15% to 36%. The total interest on a $6,500 installment loan with a 20% annual percentage rate (APR) was around $2,100 over the course of 36 months. This is less than a fifth of what the interest on credit cards would be throughout the course of their extended repayment period.
According to Marcus by Goldman Sachs, 87 percent of their customers who have personal loans use the cash for debt consolidation. The average borrower saves four thousand dollars in interest when compared to the amount of interest they would pay if they kept their credit card balances. Consumers who are concerned about their spending habits and are navigating the challenges of inflation and economic instability have taken note of this financial benefit.
The Digital Revolution in Lending
BestUSAPayday, SoFi, and Prosper are examples of online platforms that provide approval decisions in a matter of minutes and money within twenty-four hours, in contrast to the traditional bank loans that took weeks of paperwork and in-person meetings.
This level of speed and ease has been especially appealing to borrowers in the younger demographics. According to Experian’s 2024 State of Credit Report, millennials and Gen Z account for 42% of the installment loan market, and for this sector of consumers, the digital-first experience is highly sought after. Instead of feeling intimidated by walking into a bank, they can compare rates, terms and even lenders from their smartphone.
That means that the algorithmic underwriting used by modern lenders extends beyond your credit score. These lending decisions are not only based on credit card minimum requirements, but also on simple interest, employment history, education, and cash flow patterns, which help lenders explain eligibility to borrowers who may not be able to qualify for ultra credit cards.
The Merchant Partnership Ecosystem
The other significant driver for installment loan uptake has been the proliferation of point-of-sale-style loans. Installment loans have been integrated into the purchase experience at the point of sale with the help of companies like Affirm, Klarna and Afterpay, with more than 250,000 merchants worldwide offering them on everything from electronics to travel packages.
It has established installment lending as part of everyday budgeting. Best Buy also said it has seen increased use of financing for major appliance purchases, with financing making up around 23% of appliance purchases, up from just 8% in 2019. The clarity of their line stands in stark contrast to the obscurities around credit card interest calculations, with precise dollar amounts owed upfront, and servicing fees that are often at least transparent.
With Plan It options now offered by Chase, American Express, and Citi, credit card purchases have become a kind of loan with a known repayment schedule and consumers seem to appreciate some level of clarity around how to pay for something purchased on credit.
Navigating the New Landscape
While these benefits are enticing, financial advisors note that installment loans are not a cure for all credit needs. The most important thing is the right tool for the job, says Patricia Thompson, a certified financial planner in Chicago: “Installment loans are ideal for planned purchases or general debt consolidation, but they are not nearly as well-suited to pay for variable monthly expenses as credit cards.”
Additionally, the regulatory environment is undergoing change. It is possible that the landscape of installment loans will be reshaped as a result of the proposed Small Business Lending Rule by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and state-level limitations on maximum annual percentage rates. The Fair Access to Credit Act of California, which places a maximum annual percentage rate (APR) of 36% on loans ranging from $2,500 to $10,000, has already had an impact on lending practices across the country.
The Future of Consumer Credit
From this point forward, the distinction between installment loans and credit cards will continue to become increasingly hazy. Presently, hybrid products that combine revolving credit with an installment structure are beginning to appear. These products are already in existence. At the same time, developments such as artificial intelligence and open banking initiatives offer the possibility of making lending judgments that are even more expedient and individualized.
This shift is part of a larger generational shift in attitudes on debt and the management of financial resources. When compared to other types of loans, selecting an installment loan is a decision that is based on principles. These values include the need for transparency, the desire for predictability and a roadmap towards becoming debt-free.
The post Consumer Demand Trends: Why More Borrowers Choose Installment Loans Over Credit Cards appeared first on Daily Excelsior.